The New Client That Drains Your Cash

Ryan Joneson

Signing a large new client feels like the best day of the quarter. MRR jumps, the pipeline report looks great, and the P&L shows a healthy margin from the first month. Then the bank balance starts going the other way, and it keeps going for months.

Nothing is wrong with the deal. The cash problem comes from timing. Hardware, licenses and onboarding labor go out before the first full month of recurring revenue arrives. If the client pays monthly in arrears or on net 30, while license commitments are billed up front or annually, every new client opens a gap. Sign several, and the fastest-growing quarter becomes the tightest one.

Read cash flow alongside MRR

MRR tells you what a client is worth each month once everything is running. It says nothing about what you spent to get there, or when the money actually lands. The P&L doesn’t answer that either, because it records revenue when it’s earned, not when it’s paid.

Here’s a hypothetical MSP to show the arithmetic. The figures are round and invented for illustration, not typical prices or margins. It signs a 50-seat client at $7,500 a month. Serving the client costs $3,000 a month in labor and tools, plus licenses that work out to $750 a month. That leaves $3,750 a month of margin.

Getting the client live costs more up front. There’s $15,000 of hardware, folded into the monthly fee rather than billed separately. Onboarding takes 120 hours at a loaded labor cost of $75 an hour, or $9,000. The license commitment is annual and billed up front, at $9,000. The client is invoiced monthly in arrears and pays on net 30, so the first payment arrives at the end of month two.

Month Cash position on this client
At signing -$33,000
Month 1 -$36,000
Month 2 (first payment) -$31,500
Month 3 -$27,000
Month 6 -$13,500
Month 9 (paid back) $0
Month 12 (licenses renew) $4,500

 

For the first month, the bank is $36,000 worse off because of a client that the P&L says is profitable. It takes nine months for this one client to give back the cash it took to bring on. Then the annual licenses renew and take a slice of that back again.

Notice that MRR showed the full $7,500 from the first month. If you only watch MRR and gross margin per seat, nothing in those numbers warns you that this account spent most of its first year underwater.

Count the payback in months, then price for it

The most useful single number here is the payback period. Take the onboarding outlay and divide it by the monthly margin. In the example, $24,000 of hardware and onboarding labor divided by $3,750 a month is about six and a half months of margin.

The cash table says nine, not six and a half. The difference is timing: the license prepayment and the two months before the first payment arrives. That’s the gap between what the deal earns and when it pays.

Several levers change that number, and each has trade-offs with clients and competitors. They are options to weigh, not rules.

An onboarding or project fee billed at signing puts money in before the work starts. In the example, a $9,000 fee covering the onboarding hours brings payback forward from month nine to month seven. Billing hardware on delivery, rather than folding it into the monthly fee, does even more. If the client pays the $15,000 within a month, payback falls to month six.

Billing monthly in advance rather than in arrears moves every payment a month earlier. On its own, that brings payback to month eight. And aligning license commitments with the client contract matters too. Paying licenses monthly, or matching an annual commitment to a 12-month client term, keeps you from prepaying a year of cost on a client who could leave in month four.

Put all four together and the same client is cash positive by the end of month one, with its lowest point at minus $15,000 rather than minus $36,000. The client, the stack and the margin are unchanged. Only the terms moved. How contracts, leasing or financing arrangements are written is a conversation to have with your accountant or attorney.

Check the cash before you sign the next big one

One client like this is manageable. The danger comes when the good news stacks up. Sign three of them in consecutive months on the original terms, and the dips add together.

In the example, three clients signed in months zero, one and two push the combined cash position to minus $100,500 in month two. It doesn’t get back to zero until month ten. That’s the quarter the business will remember as its best for growth, and it’s the one most likely to strain payroll.

The fix isn’t to stop signing clients. It’s to look at the cash position before you do. Lay out the next six months: what’s in the bank, what each new client will cost up front, and when its first payment will actually arrive. If two big deals are closing at once, you can stagger start dates, change the terms on one, or line up funding before it’s needed.

Before signing a large new client, run these:

  • The full up-front outlay: hardware, onboarding hours at loaded cost, and any license prepayments.
  • The monthly margin once the client is live, and the payback in months.
  • When the first payment will actually arrive under the proposed billing terms.
  • Your projected bank balance for the next six months with this client and any others closing.
  • Which terms you could change, such as an onboarding fee or hardware billed on delivery, if the dip is too deep.

Ryan Joneson writes about the financial side of running a small business. He is the founder of GlassJar, which makes accounting software for small businesses and a free break-even calculator.